Lancaster Homes for Sale

Lancaster Homes for Sale

Welcome to Lancaster, New York – a charming town nestled in the heart of Erie County, where suburban tranquility meets vibrant community spirit. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly neighborhoods, Lancaster offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With a rich history dating back to the 19th century, this delightful town is home to beautiful parks, excellent schools, and a variety of local shops and restaurants that cater to all tastes.

Lancaster boasts a strong sense of community, making it an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike. Residents enjoy easy access to outdoor activities, with nearby parks such as the scenic Como Lake Park and the expansive Lancaster Town Park, perfect for picnics, walking trails, and recreational sports. The town’s commitment to preserving its green spaces ensures that you can enjoy a serene environment while still being close to the bustling city of Buffalo, just a short drive away.

For those looking to make Lancaster their home, the real estate market is thriving with a variety of homes for sale. From charming single-family houses with spacious yards to modern townhomes and condominiums, there is something for everyone. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or seeking to upgrade, Lancaster’s diverse housing options cater to various lifestyles and budgets.

Discover your dream home in Lancaster, NY, where community, comfort, and convenience come together to create an exceptional living experience. Embrace the opportunity to be part of this welcoming town and start your journey today!

Newest Lancaster Homes for Sale

5596 Genesee Street, Lancaster
$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723568 MLS
VR Pricing. Seller is considering offers between $375,000 and $425,000. 5596 Genesee Street is an extremely unique property that is perfect for an extremely unique buyer! Two metal buildings, almost one and a half acres of land, unlimited possibilities. The larger building, a 68 x 36 Morton pole barn is in excellent condition and has been converted into a 3 bedroom ranch home with one full bathroom, laundry room, huge great room and full kitchen. The smaller barn is a 32 x 20 steel building perfect for storage uses, warehouse uses, vehicle parking, you name it! Zoned A-R, the Town of Lancaster allows agricultural activities, beekeeping, forestry, kennels, small animal hospital, picnic groves, place of worship, and so much more! You'll find an abundance of residential, commercial, and parking space to suit all aspects of your unique needs. Listed as both SFR MLS B1723568 and COM Public record square footage includes both buildings-house & garage.

5596 Genesee Street, Lancaster
31 Park Boulevard, Lancaster
$269,995
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1724908 MLS
YESTERYEAR w/MODERN UPDATES! Welcome to this Classic Colonial w/timeless character & architectural details, gracefully nestled on one of THE MOST DESIRABLE STREETS IN THE VILLAGE OF LANCASTER on a dead end street near COMO PARK! Just minutes from the heart of downtown Lancaster, enjoy convenient access to charming shops, restaurants, pubs & countless community events throughout the year! Rich in character & offering the charm of a bygone era w/everyday updates of today! Side mudroom entry welcomes you into a Grand Foyer, setting the tone for elegance & conversations. French doors open to a formal dining room, while another set leads to an expansive formal living room featuring original leaded & stainless windows, a cozy gas fireplace (NRTC) & surrounding built-in shelving. Dual French doors provide a picturesque transition to the covered classic wood front porch, complete w/beautiful tongue-n-groove ceiling & inviting porch swing, the perfect spot to unwind & enjoy the neighborhood! Remarkable hardwood floors discovered throughout the entire home! Beautifully updated kitchen 2007, features breakfast bar, walk-in pantry w/built-in desk & appliances included! First floor half bath & efficient 1st floor laundry for functionality. Upstairs a Grand landing leads to a spacious primary bedroom featuring its own charming brick-face gas fireplace (NRTC) along w/two add’l bedrooms. The 2nd bedroom offers access to an enclosed rear porch, a room w/a view & little retreat! Full bathroom has a fan w/heat lamp & split tub for easy access. Piece of Mind UPGRADES include Tear off Roof 2022, Furnace 2019, Central A/C 2024, HWTank 2025, Electrical Panel 2025, Humidifier 2025 & Professionally Landscaped Grounds 2026. A bit of Nostalgia, Charm & Comfort waiting for its NEXT CHAPTER! WELCOME HOME! Offers reviewed as received with the right to reserve a deadline if warranted.

31 Park Boulevard, Lancaster
151 Peppermint Road, Lancaster
$499,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1725268 MLS
Incredible Opportunity on 11 Acres in Lancaster! Bring your vision and creativity to this sprawling ranch offering over 3,000 square feet of living space, 4 bedrooms, and 2.5 bathrooms! With great bones, generous room sizes, and endless possibilities, this property is ready for its next owner to restore it to its full potential. A roughed-in addition offers an exciting opportunity for an in-law suite, guest quarters, or additional living space. Outside, the possibilities are just as impressive! Situated on 11 acres of agriculturally zoned land, the property features an attached 2-car garage, horse barn, chicken coops, large workshop, and an inground pool. Whether you dream of a hobby farm, raising animals, enjoying wide-open spaces, or simply creating your own private retreat, this unique property offers the space and flexibility to make it happen. Conveniently located in Lancaster with easy access to surrounding amenities, this is a rare opportunity to transform a property with so much to offer into something truly special. Bring your ideas, roll up your sleeves, and imagine the possibilities! Offers reviewed as they come

151 Peppermint Road, Lancaster
2 Nashua Court, Lancaster
$450,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1725710 MLS
VRP PRICING! MOTIVATED SELLER will entertain offers between $450,000 up to $475,000 or more. RARE CUSTOM BUILT SOUTHERN STYLE CAPE w/EXCEPTIONAL CRAFTSMANSHIP nestled on a PRIVATE COURT with only 6 properties on just over 3/4 acre! Rich in History, this property is within a short distance to the Village with no Village Taxes! Truly a one-of-a-kind property offering privacy & flexibility to include over 2800 sf of creative living space & separate BONUS area for studio/office/1st floor laundry/guest/or game room on the main floor PLUS add’tl living space in Basement! The upper level features new carpeting, two spacious bedrooms, built-ins storage & deep closets & one full bath. The Lower level features three add’tl bedrooms, one currently utilized an office, along with a full bath on both floors. Welcoming front covered center entrance leads to a spacious foyer boasting Living/Dining area flowing into an impressive Open Great Room w/floor to ceiling windows flanked by soaring vaulted tongue & groove ceilings, cozy gas fireplace & deep built-in’s! Kitchen features Cherry Cabinetry, pocket door, pantry, solid surface countertops & new built in appliances. New Pella 8 foot slider opens directly to the freshly painted deck, Gazebo & concrete Patio w/partially fenced yard. Landscaped grounds have beautiful mature trees! An oversized 2.5 car side load garage w/mega Attic storage providing double entry to basement & abundant parking at both side entries! Solid Mechanics & Improvements incl: Lennox Boiler 2026, Roof 2021, Pella Windows 2008, 4 Storm doors 2025, Solo tube lighting, Generator, HWT, 200 Amp Electrical Service, 1st floor A/C w/add’l wall units upstairs & whole house fan, Sump Pump, Blacktop Driveway 2026. Let this one be YOUR next Chapter! MUST SEE!

2 Nashua Court, Lancaster
8 Northwood Drive, Lancaster
$289,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1725549 MLS
Welcome to 8 Northwood Drive centrally located in a highly sought after area close to everyday conveniences: shopping, restaurants, expressways. This impeccable maintenance free townhome has been completely redone top to bottom over the last 6 years including whole house generator.. Bright open 1st floor with vaulted ceiling, 2 story foyer, gas fireplace and hardwood floors throughout(hardwood under carpeting) Kitchen has been completely remodeled with quartzite countertops, custom glass tile backsplash, new appliances, refinished cabinets, & all new lighting. Large dining room opens to an expansive deck with remote controlled retractable awning and the backyard offers plenty of privacy, perfect for enjoying the outdoors. Upstairs you will find 2 primary suites connected by a full bath with all new custom tile walk in shower, lighting, flooring & vanity plus a large dressing area, laundry room and an abundance of storage. Full dry basement and 2 car attached garage with epoxy floor. You will no longer have to worry about shoveling, landscaping or scraping your car off in the winter! The HOA covers all exterior maintenance including roof replacement. See attachment for a full list of upgrades. Don't miss this gem! Showings begin immediately.

8 Northwood Drive, Lancaster
135 Norris Avenue, Lancaster
$239,000
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1724302 MLS
Opportunity Awaits at 135 Norris! This 4-bedroom property presents an opportunity for buyers looking to make a home their own. Featuring two bedrooms on the first floor and two additional bedrooms upstairs, the layout provides flexibility for a variety of living arrangements. The first-floor bathroom adds convenience, while the large backyard highlights plenty of outdoor space for entertaining, gardening, recreation, or future improvements. A detached one-car garage provides additional storage and parking. Whether you're looking for a place to call home or an investment opportunity, 135 Norris has the potential to make it your own. Explore the possibilities at 135 Norris!

135 Norris Avenue, Lancaster
5 Fieldstream Lane, Lancaster
$784,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1723329 MLS
What if your next home offered the space you want, the layout you need, and the opportunity to make it your own? Discover the Ryley by Forbes Capretto Homes in Fieldstream Estates. Offering 2,770 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this four-bedroom, 2.5-bath home combines an open, inviting layout with the flexibility to fit your lifestyle. A welcoming covered front porch leads into a bright main level, where expansive windows bring in natural light and the living spaces flow effortlessly together. Just off the entry, a versatile flex room offers endless possibilities, whether you envision a home office, den, creative space, or something entirely your own. Upstairs, four generously sized bedrooms are thoughtfully arranged to provide added privacy, creating a comfortable retreat from the main living areas. With room to personalize and a design that balances everyday functionality with inviting spaces, the Ryley offers more than another home to scroll past. It's an opportunity to build something that feels distinctly yours. Explore the possibilities at Fieldstream Estates! TO BE BUILT. Other floor plans available. Photos are representative of a previously built home and may show optional features, upgrades, or finishes not included in the advertised price. Specifications and availability are subject to change.

5 Fieldstream Lane, Lancaster
129 Albert Drive, Lancaster
$349,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1724611 MLS
-Open House Sat 10/31 from 11am-1pm---Welcome to this spacious, one-owner, 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial situated on a beautiful, tree-lined street in the Village of Lancaster! This well-maintained home offers plenty of space, classic charm, and numerous updates throughout. The first floor features a brand-new kitchen in 2026, complete with a new cooktop and oven, laminate flooring, solid-surface countertops, and includes the refrigerator. The kitchen overlooks the large family room, featuring new carpeting in 2026. A formal dining room just off the kitchen provides the perfect setting for gatherings and entertaining, while the generously sized front living room offers additional space to relax. A convenient half bath and welcoming foyer complete the first floor. Upstairs, you'll find four bedrooms with hardwood floors, along with newly carpeted stairs and hallway, all updated in 2026. The primary bedroom features an en-suite full bath with a brand-new walk-in shower installed in 2026. The main full bath has also been updated with a brand-new tub and surround. Additional features include a full basement with washer and dryer, a new boiler and hot water tank in 2023, and a roof replaced in 2014. Enjoy the outdoors in the fully fenced backyard, complete with a covered patio, or relax on the charming covered front porch. Conveniently located just minutes from the heart of the Village of Lancaster, you'll enjoy easy access to local shops, restaurants, community events, and all the charm this wonderful village has to offer. With its spacious layout, numerous updates, and fantastic location, this Colonial is ready to welcome you home!

129 Albert Drive, Lancaster
178 Warsaw Street, Lancaster
$169,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1723955 MLS
Welcome to 178 Warsaw, Depew, NY 14043. A home you can sit and enjoy coffee on your adorable front porch or in your private backyard. Located in the desirable Depew-Lancaster area, this home offers 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and a versatile layout featuring a living room, dining room, and family room and first floor laundry. The family room is highlighted by a vaulted ceiling, adding an open and spacious feel to the living area. With multiple gathering spaces and a convenient location, this property offers a wonderful opportunity to make it your own. Roof under 10 years old and New Windows throughout.

178 Warsaw Street, Lancaster
190 Warsaw Street, Lancaster
$229,800
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723113 MLS
Charming Depew Home with Character & Entertaining Potential! Welcome to this inviting two-story, 3-bedroom home in Depew, conveniently located just one mile from Lancaster Village’s West Main Street, known for its local restaurants, live music, festivals & community events. This home features an open & dining area & a spacious primary bedroom. The full basement includes a finished bonus room, while the attic offers additional storage. The detached garage is a standout feature, complete with built-in bar, furnace & 220 volt electrical service, perfect for entertaining or hobbies. Enjoy the full front porch with perennial gardens in the front & back yards & a six-foot vinyl privacy fence. Major updates include Furnace & Air Conditioning (2023) Replacement Windows & Sliding Back Door (2022) & Sump Pump (2021) Appliances are included for the purchaser’s convenience. With its welcoming layout, versatile extra space & convenient location, this home offers a wonderful opportunity for its future owners! Take a tour & make this your Home Sweet Home!

190 Warsaw Street, Lancaster
325 Ransom Road, Lancaster
$449,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1724148 MLS
Rare opportunity in Lancaster! Experience the perfect blend of modern luxury and ultimate privacy on this expansive 2.99-acre tree-lined parcel bordering Cayuga Creek. This turnkey property has been beautifully transformed, featuring a complete whole-house remodel in 2026. Step inside to discover a freshly painted interior accented by all-new interior doors, trim, modern flooring, and upgraded fixtures throughout. The stunning new gourmet kitchen boasts sleek cabinetry, premium countertops, and new stainless-steel appliances. The home features beautifully renovated bathrooms, including a full bath with a stunning new custom tile shower alongside a convenient half bath. The entire home is wrapped in brand-new energy-efficient windows and new exterior doors, complementing a brand-new furnace installed in 2025, central air conditioning, a new sump pump, an attached and heated 2-car garage, and a whole-house backup generator. Outside, the acreage offers a peaceful retreat with serene views and direct riparian frontage along the creek. A car enthusiast or hobbyist's absolute dream, the property also features a second, massive, towering detached 6-car outbuilding/garage. The main level provides unparalleled vehicle storage, while the spacious second story features a dedicated workshop and bonus room area—offering endless year-round potential. Located in the highly-rated Lancaster Central School District (Como Park Elementary K-3). Truly a unique, move-in-ready gem that must be seen to be appreciated!

325 Ransom Road, Lancaster
17 Bellwood Lane, Lancaster
$274,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1723332 MLS
Welcome to 17 Bellwood Lane in Depew within the Lancaster School District. This 1,266 square foot 3 bedroom, 1 bath Ranch is in excellent condition. Spacious living room has large picture window. The eat-in kitchen was remodeled in 2019 featuring white, bright cabnets & attractive countertops. Luxury vinyl floors were installed in the family room and kitchen. Fantastic family room with sliding glass door leading to a wonderful 15x14 covered patio. Fully fenced rear yard also has a 8x8 shed and backs up to Warner Estates Park/Playground. Convenient location. A great home!! Seller reserves the right to set offer deadline date.

17 Bellwood Lane, Lancaster
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!